John Spare

  • Produced Screenwriter
  • MFA in Storytelling / Scriptwriting
  • Dual BA in English and Humanities
  • 25+ Years Experience in the Film Exhibition Industry.

“At its core, every great film begins with a simple idea: a character forced to confront the impossible.”

Story is one of the most powerful forces in human culture. Long before film, television, or the written word, people gathered to share stories that helped us understand the world and our place in it. At its core, great storytelling invites an audience to follow a character on a journey—one defined by conflict, transformation, and discovery.

As a screenwriter, my goal is to craft stories that immerse audiences in compelling worlds and emotionally resonant experiences. Whether exploring psychological thrillers, supernatural horror, or thought-provoking science fiction, every script begins with a simple question: What would you do if you were placed in an impossible situation?

The answer to that question is where the story truly begins.

“THE CONJURING meets ROSEMARY’S BABY… the ideas are extremely original…The characters are well developed and the subtext, such as Don’s constant struggle with staying sober, is intriguing.  The strength of this script comes from its unique storyline and the deeper subplots that make the audience feel a deeper connection to each character.” 

⁠— William Morris Endeavor Agency review of Brockport (Black Eyed Kids original title).

Screenplays, Shorts & Pilots

Original Screenplays

Over the past decade, I’ve developed a slate of original feature screenplays, pilots, and short films that explore psychological suspense, supernatural horror, and high-concept speculative fiction. Several of these projects have earned recognition in screenwriting competitions and festivals, but more importantly, each one begins with a simple goal: tell a story audiences haven’t seen before.

Media

Annalynne McCord Outstanding Actress Sedona Film Festival - Condition of Return

“Condition of Return”, directed by Tommy Stovall and starring Dean Cain and AnnaLynne McCord, James Russo and Natasha Henstridge, opened in theaters across the country on September 22, 2003.

Let's Collaborate.

John E. Spare

Before The Third Day

Drama, Conspiracy, Sci Fi, Adventure

An atheist historian is recruited by the Catholic Church for a secret mission involving a forbidden sacrament, only to uncover a conspiracy buried deep within the events surrounding the crucifixion.

The premise is fantastic. Very powerful. The juxtaposition of Kristoff from the beginning to the last shot is right up there with Planet of The Apes and The Usual Suspects.” – Produced Screenwriter & Published Author Elise D’Haene

“Kristoff is a complex, tragically flawed protagonist. He’s definitely got the stuff to carry the movie. His intelligence shines through, along with his dark sense of humor. The rest of the characters are also never less than interesting, due to the strength of the dialogue.” – Story Analyst For Major Studio/ Scripthop’s Guantlet Feedback

Cold Quiet Country

Drama, Suspense, Mystery

When a string of brutal deaths rocks a small Wyoming town in 1971, a teenage drifter becomes the prime suspect — hunted across a frozen landscape by a sadistic sheriff whose sins run deeper than anyone knows. Based on Clayton Lindemuth’s critically acclaimed novel.

“...exciting and suspenseful…realistic and heartbreaking.”  ⁠- The Black List

Condition of Return

Thriller, Horror, Suspense

Guilty of mass murder, a young elementary teacher must convince a failed pshychologist she is sane in order to receive the death penalty.

There are scenes that leave us at the edge of our seats, filled with electric tension.”  – Stage 32 Happy Writers 

Brockport

Horror, Suspense, Thriller

When his pregnant wife vanishes, a small-town Pennsylvania sheriff discovers the evil that took her doesn’t break down doors — it knocks. And a town that prides itself on friendliness never learned to say no to a stranger.

“BROCKPORT has a numinous texture that evokes an air of 1970s horror films, part THE EXORCIST, part THE OMEN, and a bit of LET’S SCARE JESSICA TO DEATH. ” – The Black List

Crisis

Drama, Supsense, Thriller

An unassuming family man struggles to maintain his secret life as a “crisis actor” forced to appear at catastrophic events orchestrated by a covert government cabal with a sinister agenda.

The Better Half

Suspense, Thriller

A desperate wife in a loveless marriage is shocked by the sudden transformation of her abusive husband.

Cheat

Drama, Supsense, Thriller

A lonely husband makes a fateful mistake during a business trip when sharing a drink with a seemingly friendly stranger.

Soccer Mom Mafia

Comedy

A newly divorced financially strapped mom struggles to exact revenge on her misogynistic ex, empowering a motley group of women to secretly right the daily wrongs of suburban life.

Horror, Suspense, Thriller

I grew up in the first generation of homes that owned a VCR. Ours happened to be a clunky Betamax my father bought a few years after they became “affordable,” but to a ten-year-old kid it felt like the greatest invention since color television. That machine let me record movies off cable and watch them again and again—studying them without realizing I was studying them.

But the real beginning happened earlier. My father took me to the movies almost every week. I still remember sitting in dark theaters watching a donkey kick field goals, an underdog boxer fighting just to go the distance, and a young mechanic from a galaxy far, far away taking on an empire. When Showtime finally reached our rural town, it opened another door. Suddenly Kubrick, Scorsese, and dozens of other filmmakers were playing in our living room.

That Betamax became my film school.

In college I took a job as an usher at the local theater, which meant I could watch first-run films for free. While earning a dual degree in English and Humanities, I started thinking that maybe I belonged in the movie business. In 1992 I joined a small theater company as a manager and eventually worked my way up to Senior Vice President of Destinta Theatres, a multi-state megaplex circuit. For twenty years I lived and breathed movies—from the business side of the industry.

Then something unexpected happened.

In 2011 I watched David Seidler accept the Academy Award for The King’s Speech. He was seventy-four years old. That moment hit me like a lightning bolt. I was forty-one, had an English degree I had never truly used, decades of experience watching audiences react to films, and a lifelong love of storytelling. For the first time I realized something simple but terrifying: if I didn’t start writing now, I probably never would.

So I started.

I read everything I could about the craft—Syd Field, Robert McKee, Blake Snyder, Stephen King—and eventually sat down to write my first feature screenplay. That script, Condition of Return, a psychological thriller exploring faith and morality, began gaining recognition in competitions and festivals, including positive reads from the Nicholl Fellowship. More importantly, it proved something to me: this was what I was meant to do.

Since then I’ve continued writing a slate of original features, pilots, and short films. Some have won or placed in festivals and competitions, others are still evolving, but every script begins with the same goal—to tell a story that challenges characters, provokes audiences, and lingers long after the final scene.

My father passed away in 2012 after a long battle with cancer. A week before he died, he told me he was proud of me—not just for my career or my family, but because I had the courage to chase the dream I’d always talked about. That moment meant more than any award ever could.

Writing has never been about fame or money for me. It’s about the simple, stubborn drive to create stories that matter.

And it all started with a kid, a Betamax machine, and a father who loved going to the movies.

— John Spare

Media & Awards

Awards

Nominee Best Hour-Long Television Teleplay

Oil Valley Film Festival, Nominee Best Hour-Long Television Teleplay “Crisis”

Semifinalist—The First 10 Pages Script Contest

The First 10 Pages Script Contest, Semifinalist “Cloning Christ”

Best Comedy Screenplay—IHolly Film Festival

IHolly Film Festival, Best Comedy Screenplay “Unreality”

Best Adapted Screenplay—Rebel Seed Entertainment

Adapted Screenplay Competition, Winner “Cold Quiet Country”

Preliminary Finalist — Best Horror/Thriller Screenplay

Creative World Awards, Preliminary Finalist “Black Eyed Kids”

Nominee—Best Screenplay

Beverly Hills Film Festival, Nominee Best Screenplay “Cold Quiet Country”

Semifinalist—Celtx Screenwriting Fellowship

Celtx Screenwriting Fellowship—”Condition of Return”

Best Screenplay—Naperville Independent Film Festival

Naperville Independent Film Festival, Best Screenplay “Condition of Return”

Semi-Finalist—Best Feature Screenplay

Creative World Awards, Semifinalist “Condition of Return”

Semifinalist—Best Thriller Screenplay

Acclaim Scripts, Semifinalist “Condition of Return”

QuarterFinalist—Best Feature Female Protagonist Screenplay

Cynosure, Quarterfinalist “Condition of Return”

Second Round Quarterfinalist—Best Horror Screenplay

Page International Screenwriting Awards, Second Round Quarterfinalist “Condition of Return”

Semifinalist—Best Thriller Screenplay

Reel Authors Screenplay Contest, Best Thriller Screenplay “Condition of Return”

Quarter Finalist—Best Comedy Screenplay

Reel Authors Screenplay Contest, Best Comedy Screenplay “Unreality”

Media